Annex D: Definition
and Calculation of Value Factor
National Master Standing Offer
EZ107-060001/001/VAN to EZ107-060001/006/VAN
Desktop and Network Printers including Accessories, Supplies and Services
Annex D: Definition and Calculation of Value Factor
1. Definition of "Value Factor"
"Value Factor" is the term used in this Standing Offer for determining
the Products offering the best value to the Government of Canada, based on
the evaluated price and the benchmark score for that Product. The best Value
Factor is the Product with the highest score for Value Factor in accordance
with this Annex.
The Value Factor will be determined in order to select Offerors
for issuance of resulting Standing Offers, to determine the applicable
Call-up Limitation, and to determine the "Active Offerors" during each
monthly period following a downward price revision.
The Value Factor for each printer will be calculated based on
two elements:
(1) the Evaluated Price (calculated as set out below); and
(2) the total Benchmark Score.
2. Step 1 - Calculation of "Evaluated Price"
Within each Sub-Category of printers the "Evaluated Price" per
unit will be the sum of the following:
(a) The weighted average of the unit prices (each unit price must
be equal to or lower than that of the preceeding order size
tier) submitted for the five pricing tiers for the printer (including
all equipment required for the printer to meet the minimum
specifications for the Sub-Category - for purposes of the financial
and technical evaluation, all printers offered in network Sub-Categories
must be configured and priced with an Ethernet 10/100 Base T or
100 Base T Network Interface Card), including one full set of initial
consumables, user manuals, configuration, delivery, and the provision
of one-year of Warranty Service (on-site where applicable, as described
in the Resulting Contract clauses and Hot Swap Warranty Service
for all other locations), inclusive of travel, labour and parts
replacement.
(b)
The weighted average of the unit prices (each unit price must
be equal to or lower than that of the preceeding order size
tier) submitted for the five identified tiers for the installation
of the printer at final destination. The average installation
price will be used to calculate the Evaluated Price for each
unit offered, even though installation will not necessarily
be requested by all Authorized Users.
(c)
The weighted average of the unit prices (each unit price must
be equal to or lower than that of the preceeding order size
tier) submitted for the five identified tiers for the upgrade
of the Warranty Services from one year to four years, on-site
where applicable, inclusive of all travel, labour and parts
replacement.
(d)
The Imaging Consumables Cost Factor (the total cost of imaging
consumables, other than paper, to produce a specified number
of prints at a specified page coverage, which will be calculated
using Tier 1 pricing only).
The weights which will be used for the purposes of calculating the weighted
average unit prices (a, b, and c) above, will be as follows for both Group
1 and Group 2:
| Tier 1 |
Tier 2 |
Tier 3 |
Tier 4 |
Tier 5 |
| 40% |
30% |
10% |
10% |
10% |
The following is an example of the calculation of the Value Factor:
| Cost components |
Tier 1 |
Tier 2 |
Tier 3 |
Tier 4 |
Tier 5 |
| Cost of Printer |
$7,000.00 |
$6,700.00 |
$6,500.00 |
$6,200.00 |
$5,900.00 |
| Installation at Client Site |
$50.00 |
$45.00 |
$37.00 |
$32.00 |
$30.00 |
| Upgrade to 4 yr site warranty |
$356.00 |
$280.00 |
$260.00 |
$200.00 |
$150.00 |
| Add Consumable Factor |
Will be the same across all tiers ($6,095.00) |
| Total Cost Factor |
$13,501.00 |
$13,120.00 |
$12,892.00 |
$12,527.00 |
$12,175.00 |
| Weighted Average of Cost Factor |
$5,400.40 |
$3,936.00 |
$1,289.20 |
$1,252.70 |
$1,217.50 |
| Total Weighted Average of Cost Factor |
$13,095.80 |
|
|
|
|
2. Step 2 - Benchmark Score
The Benchmark Score will be determined by NSTL. The maximum Benchmark
Score for each printer is 10.
3. Step 3 - Calculation of "Value Factor"
The elements will be combined at a ratio of 70% for Total Weighted
Average of Cost Factor to 30% for benchmark points. The lowest
Total Weighted Average of Cost Factor will achieve 70 points and all other
Offerors' Total Weighted Average of Cost Factors will be pro-rated accordingly.
The Offeror achieving the highest total benchmark points will
achieve 30 points and all the other Offerors' total points will be pro-rated
accordingly. The Value Factor will be the sum of the each of the two elements
after they are prorated.
Example:
| ELEMENT 1 |
Vendor A |
Vendor B |
Vendor C |
Vendor D |
Total Weighted
Average
of Cost Factor |
$15,356.78 |
$ 14,120.30 |
$13,095.80 |
$ 18,340.00 |
| |
|
|
|
|
| Cost rating (Pro-rated against lowest cost) |
59.69 |
64.92 |
70.00 |
49.98 |
| |
|
|
|
|
Ex. VENDOR A = $13,095.80 x 70
$15,356.78 |
|
|
|
| ELEMENT 2 |
Vendor A |
Vendor B |
Vendor C |
Vendor D |
| NSTL Score |
8.70 |
7.50 |
7.13 |
7.16 |
| Benchmark Points rating (Pro-rated against highest) |
| |
30.00 |
25.86 |
24.59 |
24.69 |
Ex. VENDOR C = 7.13 x 30 8.70 |
|
|
|
|
| |
|
|
|
|
| SUMMARY |
Cost |
Benchmark Points |
Sum |
Rank |
| Vendor A |
59.69 |
30.00 |
89.69 |
3 |
| Vendor B |
64.92 |
25.86 |
90.78 |
2 |
| Vendor C |
70.00 |
24.59 |
94.59 |
1 |
| Vendor D |
49.98 |
24.69 |
74.67 |
4 |
| |
|
|
|
|
|